CARBON POLITICS
In the same week that the entire world (minus the United States) got together to determine the threat of human caused climate change, a study published in the journal Nature Sustainability notes that the total CO2 emissions from Hyperscale Data Centers rival that of nations like Paraguay.
This study was first reported widely by the New York Times, and demonstrates the current scale of CO2 emissions by data centers. While some proposed projects might rely on “green energy,” or renewable resources like wind and solar power, to fuel their massive computations; many rely on electric generators powered by natural gas turbines.
While concerns have arisen concerning the air quality impact of individual data centers, this study examines currently operating data centers, and calculates the total CO2 consumed during electricity generation by both on-site natural gas turbines, and by grid power that originally comes from natural gas or coal.
Some of the largest data centers examined in the study produced 25.7 metric tons of CO2 emissions annually, a number which the New York Times reported rivaled the total output of Denmark or Uruguay.
What The Study Taught Us
Researchers at Harvard were unable to locate officially reported emission data for most data centers reviewed in the study, and instead had to use satellite data to calculate square footage of the facilities, and work backwards to determine the amount of electricity that would be required. This means that the amounts in the study are estimates, in part, but might not reflect the total output due to variations in machinery and other factors.
They found that in states like Virginia, home to more large scale data centers than any other state, around 7 million metric tons of carbon dioxide were released annually.
In states like Texas, which have seen a massive boom in data center development, consumed around 1.3 million metric tons.
To put this in comparison with carbon consumption we’re already aware of, the two largest emitters of carbon dioxide in the world, China and the United States, released an estimated 13 billion and 4 billion metric tons annually.
Many smaller nations release carbon dioxide in amounts that are near the amounts reported of data centers in the study. Paraguay and Jamaica each were responsible for around 8 million tons. Collectively, among all the states analyzed in the study, over 25 million tons.
That means that the amount of carbon dioxide emitted by data centers collectively throughout the United States rivals that of much larger nations entire annual outputs, such as Jordan or Switzerland.
The Difficulties of Calculating True Carbon Consumption
The researchers admit in the study that their calculation is not perfect, as there was no way to reasonably differentiate between pre-existing computer processing, like servers and others uses.
However, the study represents one of the first all encompassing reviews of current data technology in the United States to analyze carbon dioxide specifically.
The study also does not calculate the amount of carbon dioxide emitted during the construction of the facilities.
While many data centers in Texas report in their Air Quality Permit Applications to the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality report that their annual emissions would be no more than a few thousand metric tons of CO2 (this varies greatly on size), the amount of carbon dioxide released during the contraction phase would dwarf that amount.
Concrete is already one of the most carbon intensive industrial products on Earth, not to mention the massive quantities of diesel fuel needed to construct and transport materials.
Putting The Results in Context
It is currently accepted by virtually all climate researchers that carbon dioxide emissions lead to the progression of the “Greenhouse Effect” in the Earth’s atmosphere; trapping heat and causing global ocean temperatures to rise.
The goal of climate accords, such as the 2015 Paris Climate accords, is to establish collective goals in limiting greenhouse gas emissions, to achieve a certain target of limiting warming by a set number of degrees.
In 2015, this point was set at a 1.5 degrees celsius gain in ocean water temperatures. But it is now known that this point has already been reached. During this years COP31 climate summit, the target goal was set higher, around 2.6 degrees Celsius.
Most alternative theories about global warming are based in misinformation, or misunderstanding of the true problem.
Ultimately, the world, and countries like China and America, have an over-consumption problem.


